A missing figure skater brings Emily and Sam together on a new investigation in Mistletoe Murders season 3 episode 3, “We Three Kims, Part 1.” What begins with a blood-covered skate soon raises questions about the people closest to Kimmy Baker, especially when evidence suggests her disappearance may have been planned.
Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Episode 3 Recap: Kimmy Disappears
A traveling skating production called Christmas on Ice arrives in town, but rehearsals are already tense. Derek, the show’s male lead, criticizes his skating partner Kimmy Baker for struggling with her turns. John, the choreographer, defends her, while Kimmy admits to fellow performer KJ that the transition to the production has been difficult.
Personal tensions run through the company, too. John has recently become engaged to KJ, although Derek suspects there is something going on between John and Kimmy.
Kimmy returns to the rink for a private practice session. She records herself skating so she can review her performance, but someone unexpectedly enters the building. Kimmy approaches the visitor, and her recording captures a frightened scream.
When John arrives later, Kimmy is missing. He finds her abandoned phone and a blood-covered skate on the ice.
Sam takes charge of the investigation. John explains that he arrived early to use the gym and discovered the evidence while looking for Kimmy. He also says he has been unable to contact her manager, Paula.
Derek, KJ, and Paula confirm that Kimmy was last seen after rehearsal, when Derek accompanied her back to the hotel.
Emily recognizes Kimmy’s name when Sam mentions the case. Once a promising Olympic figure skater, Kimmy suffered an injury that ended her hopes of winning gold. Emily offers to help investigate, although Sam initially insists he can manage on his own.
Derek Suspects John Is Involved in Kimmy’s Disappearance
Emily’s interest in the case leads her to Sue’s diner, where she encounters an argument between John and Derek.
Derek openly suspects John of Kimmy’s disappearance. John responds by accusing Derek of dating Kimmy to benefit from her skating career. KJ attempts to calm the confrontation, but Derek eventually leaves.
Emily also learns that John is Sue’s nephew.
Sue explains that they had been estranged for years following a disagreement involving John’s decision to leave medical school. She had encouraged him to pursue his ambitions, which caused problems with his family. Sue later distanced herself, hoping he would reconcile with them, but that never happened. With Christmas on Ice coming to town, Sue finally reached out to him again.
John’s relationship with KJ is also suffering. When he believes she shares Derek’s suspicions, he becomes upset and leaves the diner.
The investigation produces another important detail when Sam confirms that the blood on the skate belongs to Kimmy. Unfortunately, the skate itself cannot provide useful DNA evidence because it belongs to the rink and has been used by several people.
Sam also receives a call from a lawyer representing the Zarkoff family, who sponsored Kimmy’s skating career and became something of an adoptive family to her. Emily suggests speaking to Ray, who may know more about the family. Ray warns them to be careful and offers to look into the Zarkoffs.
A Private Investigator Was Following Kimmy and John
A photograph Brooke took during rehearsals gives Sam another lead. While looking at the image in Brooke’s Christmas newsletter, he notices an unfamiliar man standing in the background.
Emily later spots the same man near the rink, but he drives away before she can speak to him. Although she cannot read his license plate, she remembers a distinctive piece of cardboard attached to his car. Sam recalls seeing the vehicle near the rink on the day Kimmy disappeared and requests security footage.
Their investigation eventually identifies the man as Chuck, a private investigator posing as a pizza delivery driver. Chuck admits that Derek hired him to follow Kimmy and John because he suspected they were having an affair. After several days of surveillance, however, Chuck found no evidence of a romantic relationship. He photographed the pair and gave the images to Derek, who has only paid half his fee.
Chuck also explains that he ran away from Emily because he mistook her for a former client. The revelation gives Sam another reason to question Derek, who has been particularly vocal about John’s possible involvement.
At Under the Mistletoe, Kimmy’s manager Paula offers a different account of the relationships within the production. She describes Kimmy as popular with the cast and crew and maintains that Kimmy and Derek have a strong relationship. Paula also mentions that Derek wants to take over managing Kimmy’s career.

The Search for Kimmy Leads to a Frozen Lake
The investigation becomes more troubling when police locate Kimmy’s abandoned rental car.
Investigators find an ice auger, a tool used to drill through frozen surfaces, in the trunk. Sam orders divers to search a nearby lake, where investigators discover blood leading toward a hole in the ice. They do not recover Kimmy’s body.
The evidence raises the possibility that someone killed her and disposed of her remains beneath the frozen surface. Emily, however, notices details that don’t fit that explanation. At the rink, she examines the blood left behind and questions why there is no trail consistent with someone dragging Kimmy away.
She also studies the recording on Kimmy’s phone. Whoever approached her entered from an area outside the camera’s view, suggesting that the person may have known the rink and Kimmy’s practice routine. During another visit, Emily encounters Derek sharpening his skates.
He continues to accuse John of having a relationship with Kimmy and says he’s frustrated that the production’s investors postponed the show rather than canceled it. They have already arranged a replacement for Kimmy.
Emily and Sam Agree to Work Together
Although Sam initially resisted Emily’s involvement, her observations have become useful to the investigation. After the search at the lake, he visits Under the Mistletoe and admits that the case has been difficult.
Their conversation also turns personal.
Sam tells Emily he would like to spend more time with her while she is in town and invites her to a public skating event. Emily remains hesitant about restarting their romantic relationship. Instead, Sam asks whether she would officially help him investigate Kimmy’s disappearance.
Emily agrees, giving them a reason to spend more time together while they continue working through their unresolved feelings.

Violet and Kyle Try to Make the Most of Christmas
Elsewhere, Kyle surprises Violet by returning to town a day earlier than expected. His visit comes with disappointing news. He can only stay for one week because his parents want him to spend Christmas with his grandparents.
Violet and Kyle decide to squeeze their planned holiday activities into the shorter visit. They go to a ski resort and spend time playing Christmas-themed board games at Sue’s diner.
Kyle also mentions that his relationship with his father has been awkward. He hopes they can visit a Christmas escape room together, especially since his father recently started working there as a custodian. Later, Violet creates a homemade drive-in movie experience using a tablet inside a car.
When the tablet runs out of battery, she suggests they simply enjoy spending time together. Kyle instead decides to call it a night because they have another busy day planned. Their limited time together keeps bringing up difficulties, even as they try to make the visit special.

Emily’s Flashbacks Reveal Another Encounter With Aaron
The episode also returns to Emily’s past through flashbacks involving Thomas and Aaron.
During a Christmas Eve mission, Emily and Thomas are assigned to stop hackers planning a power outage. Thomas orders Emily to observe the location without engaging anyone unless he authorizes it.
When she sees two hooded figures entering an unmarked doorway, Emily wants to investigate. Thomas tells her to remain where she is. She moves closer anyway and recognizes Aaron’s motorcycle outside the building. Emily asks Thomas for permission to continue, but he orders her to withdraw.
She begins to suspect that Thomas is deliberately preventing her from finding Aaron. Before she can get an explanation, someone attacks her from behind. The flashbacks stop there.

John and KJ’s Engagement Falls Apart
Back in the present, Sue tells Emily that John and KJ have ended their engagement. Hoping to comfort her nephew, Sue prepares his favorite soup. Emily offers to deliver it because she is already planning to visit the rink.
Sam, meanwhile, questions Derek about hiring Chuck.
Derek admits he hired the investigator but claims he lost the hard drive containing Chuck’s photographs before he could examine it. Sam remains suspicious and seeks a warrant to search Derek’s rental suite. At the rink, Emily witnesses Derek quitting the production after confronting John about Kimmy’s replacement.
She also speaks with KJ, who has recently met with Paula and hired her as a manager.
KJ explains that Derek told her the private investigator found no evidence of an affair. When she shared that information with John, he ended their engagement. She also claims to have lost the hard drive after leaving it in the pocket of one of her jackets.
The missing photographs could help Emily and Sam determine whether Derek’s suspicions have any basis.
Emily Finds the Missing Hard Drive
Ray returns with concerning information about the Zarkoffs. The family is sending its own people to investigate Kimmy’s disappearance, and Ray fears they could resort to violence.
Emily also contacts her CIA superior to ask about the family, but Brooke interrupts her, wanting Under the Mistletoe to participate in the Christmas Market.
Their discussion gives Emily an idea.
Remembering that Brooke took photographs at the rink, she asks whether Brooke has seen KJ’s missing jacket. Brooke explains that she found the jacket and handed it over to lost and found. Emily retrieves it and discovers that Chuck’s hard drive is still in the pocket. She also notices a small drop of blood on the hood.
The blood is especially suspicious because Kimmy wasn’t wearing the jacket when she disappeared. Emily takes the hard drive to the police station, where she and Sam examine Chuck’s photographs. As Chuck claimed, there is no evidence of an affair between John and Kimmy. But the images contain something much more important.
Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Episode 3 Ending Explained: Did John Help Kimmy Disappear?
While reviewing the photographs, Emily notices a bag from a hardware store outside town. Other images show the ice auger being placed in the trunk of Kimmy’s rental car. Investigators found the same type of tool after locating her abandoned vehicle.
The photographs give Emily and Sam reason to reconsider the apparent kidnapping.
The blood on the rink’s ice, the hole in the frozen lake, and the evidence surrounding Kimmy’s car had suggested a violent crime. Now, the possibility emerges that some of those clues were deliberately arranged.
Emily and Sam rush back to the rink to confront John. They accuse him of helping Kimmy stage her own kidnapping and apparent death.
The episode ends before John confirms or denies their accusation.
The new evidence suggests Kimmy may have faked her disappearance, although Emily and Sam still don’t know where she is or why she would do it.
They suspect John helped her, but they still haven’t proven it.
For now, the mystery remains unsolved. With the Zarkoff family also looking for Kimmy, Emily and Sam will have more questions to answer in “We Three Kims, Part 2.”

