The mystery surrounding Richard’s death finally gets an answer in Mistletoe Murders season 3 episode 2, “Don’t Fear the Wreather, Part 2.” Emily and Sam investigate several suspects before discovering who was really on the roof that night. Meanwhile, Emily’s Christmas Cheerman campaign brings some unexpected developments, and her past threatens to interfere with her relationship with Sam.
Emily and Sam Find New Suspects in Richard’s Murder
The episode picks up with Helen’s release from police custody. Sam explains to Emily that the misunderstanding involving Albert has been cleared up. Albert’s wife had asked Helen to feed their fish while they were away, but Albert unexpectedly stayed home. Helen had a legitimate reason to be at the house, although Richard’s murder remains unsolved.
Unfortunately, Wes has already decided that Helen is guilty. He speaks to local reporters outside the police station, publicly accusing her of killing Richard. Sam intervenes and explains that the investigation is ongoing and that Helen’s visit to the station was unrelated.
Emily has other responsibilities waiting at Under the Mistletoe, where she is organizing a gift drive and beginning her campaign for Christmas Cheerman. Violet is excited about her decision to run, although Emily reminds her that it doesn’t mean she will move back permanently.
June soon interrupts with news of a competing campaign event. Brooke has attracted a crowd with promotional giveaways, including cookies bearing the name “Ginger-Brooke.” She has little respect for Emily’s candidacy, even when June warns her not to underestimate Emily.
The murder investigation becomes more complicated when Emily encounters Ruth at Sue’s. Ruth supports Wes’s public accusations against Helen and admits that she previously urged her father to protect his finances during his marriage. Richard responded by threatening to cut her off.
Emily shares the conversation with Sam, but Ruth’s account isn’t enough to establish Helen’s guilt.
Mayor Ray then produces another possible lead. Two years earlier, Richard fined Albert for excessive electricity use, creating a dispute that could have given Albert a reason to resent him.
When Emily and Sam question Helen, she provides more context about both conflicts. She says she originally wanted Richard to exclude her from his estate, but he worried that Ruth wouldn’t support her. Helen also confirms that Richard and Albert’s relationship deteriorated after the fine.
According to Helen, Richard suspected Albert of interfering with his Christmas decorations and had considered installing surveillance cameras. Helen persuaded him against taking the matter further.

Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Episode 2 Recap: The Hidden Camera
As Emily and Sam leave Helen’s property, Emily notices something unusual about the wiring on a decorative reindeer. A closer inspection reveals a concealed camera behind its red nose.
The footage provides the first substantial breakthrough in the investigation.
Reviewing the recording at Emily’s house, they discover that Albert moved the ladder away from Richard’s house. Sam brings him in for questioning, but Albert insists that his actions were intended as a prank and that he didn’t cause Richard’s death.
Another footprint is also found on the roof. Albert denies that it belongs to him and says he didn’t see anyone else there.
However, he remembers noticing Ruth’s car parked nearby. That detail gives Sam and Emily another reason to examine her movements on the night of the murder.
Richard’s lawyer subsequently confirms that Richard intended to meet with him shortly before his death to add Helen to his will. Since Ruth had already objected to the marriage, Emily and Sam consider whether she discovered her father’s plans.
The investigation now has several possible suspects, but none of the evidence establishes who actually killed Richard.

Emily and Sam Discuss Their Relationship
The case also brings Emily and Sam closer together.
Before Emily leaves the police station, Sam admits how much he has missed her. Emily feels the same way, although neither is ready to resume their relationship while her situation remains unresolved.
They agree to wait until Emily has dealt with her past and can consider returning to town full-time.
That past continues to appear through flashbacks involving Aaron.
In one, Emily remembers Aaron entering an intelligence building and asking her to join him. He tells her that he loves her, but Emily refuses to follow him. Instead, she triggers a lockdown alarm to prevent his escape.
A later memory reveals that Aaron was responsible for a data breach that resulted in the deaths of some of Emily’s colleagues. These scenes explain why Emily cannot simply leave her former life behind, even as her connection with Sam grows stronger.
Elsewhere, she speaks with Wes about his resentment toward Helen. Drawing on her experience of losing her parents when she was young, Emily encourages him to consider forgiveness. Wes remains convinced that Helen murdered Richard.
Why Does Emily Withdraw From the Christmas Cheerman Election?
Emily’s campaign becomes increasingly difficult to reconcile with her uncertain future in town.
Sam tells Violet that encouraging Emily to run could make her eventual departure more painful. Violet agrees to stop pressuring her, although June remains determined to help Emily win. As the debate approaches, June shares that she has started dating again without much success. She also encourages Emily to pursue a relationship with Sam.
Their conversation is interrupted when Ray reports a FOR SALE sign outside Richard and Helen’s house.
Emily visits Helen and learns that Ruth has decided to sell the property immediately. During their conversation, Helen also explains why she left Wes with relatives as a child.
She says she wanted to protect him from knowing how badly his father had been struggling before his death. Richard later encouraged her to contact Wes with a Christmas card, but the attempt at reconciliation failed.
Emily returns to the debate after Brooke has finished promoting her plans to restore the town’s Christmas Market.
Instead of delivering the speech June and Violet prepared, Emily makes a different announcement. She withdraws from the election because she cannot promise the town the commitment the position deserves. She then encourages the community to reconsider its judgment of Helen and proposes her as an alternative candidate.
The speech receives applause, and Ray opens the voting.

How Do Emily and Sam Discover Who Killed Richard?
While Emily attends the debate, Sam questions Ruth about her presence near Richard’s house.
Ruth admits that she parked nearby because she was upset about her father’s decision to support Helen. She maintains that she never went onto the roof. She also reminds Sam that Richard was holding one of Helen’s red mittens when his body was discovered, a detail that continues to cast suspicion on Helen.
Emily believes they need a different approach to identify the killer.
Sam summons Ruth and Albert to the station and announces that specialists will examine the roof using advanced forensic technology. He tells them to stay away from the property, so their presence doesn’t interfere with the examination. The announcement is a trap designed to lure anyone with something to hide back to the crime scene.
Emily prepares for a stakeout at Helen’s house while Sam watches Ruth at the diner. Emily initially expects Albert might return to interfere with the evidence. However, after noticing Helen’s shears outside, she begins considering another possibility.
She hears someone moving on the roof and climbs up to investigate.
The person she finds is Wes.
He is pouring bleach over the area where Richard died, attempting to destroy evidence.
Wes admits that he was on the roof the night of Richard’s death, but claims he only wanted to warn Richard about Helen. Emily rejects his explanation and accuses him of killing Richard and trying to make Helen appear responsible. Wes continues to deny the accusation, but his next actions put Emily’s life in danger.
How Does Emily Escape From Wes?
Wes pushes Emily off the roof. She manages to catch the edge, leaving her hanging above the ground while Wes repeatedly kicks at her hands.
Emily attempts to contact Sam, but Wes knocks her phone away. Sam answers the call and realizes something is wrong when Emily doesn’t respond. He immediately drives toward the house. Wes believes Emily has no way to escape. She has another plan.
After checking her watch, Emily tells him that she knows something he doesn’t. It is almost seven o’clock, the time Richard’s elaborate Christmas lights are programmed to switch on. When the lights suddenly illuminate the roof, Wes is temporarily blinded.
Emily uses the opportunity to pull herself back to safety. By the time Wes can see properly again, she is standing behind him.
Sam arrives to find that Emily has already subdued Wes. She brings him out with his hands restrained by Christmas lights.
The investigation has finally identified Richard’s killer.

What Happens to Helen and the Christmas Cheerman Election?
The following day, Ray and Helen visit Under the Mistletoe with news about the election.
Despite withdrawing from the race, Emily has won. Her speech persuaded enough townspeople to vote for her anyway. Emily appreciates the gesture but declines the position.
Helen also refuses to take the role. With the accusations against her cleared, her wreath business has recovered, and she has plenty of work to keep her occupied. There has also been a change in her relationship with Ruth. The two have reconciled, Ruth has withdrawn the house from the market, and she is now helping Helen with the business.
That leaves Brooke as the next candidate in line for Christmas Cheerman. Emily accepts the outcome and expresses confidence that Brooke will do well.
Sam later visits Emily and confirms that the murder investigation is closed. Wes is responsible for Richard’s death. He also returns to their personal situation. Sam believes they work well together and tells Emily that he is willing to be wherever she is. He leaves her with something to consider, but Emily doesn’t answer.
Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Episode 2 Ending Explained: Why Must Emily Return to Intelligence Work?
The final scene introduces another complication for Emily and Sam. After receiving a message from an unknown number, Emily meets her former intelligence superior inside a black SUV.
Emily believed she had been allowed to spend the holidays away from her previous work. Her former boss reminds her that the arrangement comes with conditions.
In exchange for protecting Emily’s former colleagues and providing them with new identities, Emily agreed to return to active duty until Aaron and Chimera are caught.
Emily argues that their efforts cannot bring Thomas back, but her superior insists that she honor the agreement.
There is also a strict requirement: Emily must keep her intelligence work secret, including from Sam.
The ending confirms that Emily is still obligated to work for her former intelligence agency. Her time away is temporary, and the agreement remains in place.
That makes Sam’s earlier offer especially complicated. He is prepared to build a future around Emily’s circumstances, but he doesn’t know about the work she is expected to resume or the secrecy demanded of her.
