The moment Guarding Stars was announced with Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki as its leads, I think an entire generation of millennials got excited. Blair Waldorf and Dean Forester in a Christmas romance? That alone was enough to get my attention.
Thankfully, Netflix’s adaptation of Katherine Center’s The Bodyguard has more going for it than the nostalgia of seeing two familiar faces from Gossip Girl and Gilmore Girls. It’s a genuinely enjoyable Christmas movie, with plenty of romance, family moments, and emotion.
The story follows Hannah Brooks (Meester), a former military officer working in private security who is hired to protect Hollywood star Jack Stapleton (Padalecki) from a stalker. When Jack returns to his family’s Montana ranch for Christmas, Hannah pretends to be his girlfriend so his recovering mother won’t discover he’s in danger.
It’s the kind of setup that practically guarantees a Christmas romance, and I was more than happy to go along.

Guarding Stars review: Leighton Meester is the MVP
For me, Leighton Meester is easily the standout.
She makes Hannah convincing as a badass bodyguard who can take care of herself and everyone around her, while also showing the more vulnerable side of a woman who has never experienced the kind of family Christmas the Stapletons take for granted.
Hannah is used to being independent, keeping people at a distance, and dealing with her problems on her own. Watching her slowly become comfortable around Jack’s family gives the romance something more meaningful.
Meester handles both sides of Hannah beautifully, and I especially enjoyed the contrast between the woman who can put Jack on the ground in seconds and the one discovering what it feels like to belong somewhere.
Another MVP deserves a mention: Andie MacDowell as Connie Stapleton. She’s wonderful as Jack’s loving mother, whose warmth helps make the family Christmas feel so inviting. The Stapletons are a big part of why the movie works for me.
And, of course, there’s Padalecki. Seeing him and Meester together is a treat, especially if, like me, you grew up watching their respective shows.
There’s also a fun connection behind the camera. Two of the film’s four credited writers, Erin Cardillo and Richard Keith, work on Netflix’s Virgin River, so the romance experience was certainly there. Between that and the casting, I was excited about this movie long before I watched it.

How does Guarding Stars compare with Katherine Center’s The Bodyguard?
Having read The Bodyguard, I understand why some fans of the novel might have reservations about the adaptation.
The original book isn’t a Christmas story, so turning it into a holiday movie required changes. Adapting a novel into a film also creates differences compared with a longer television series.
One of the biggest is Hannah’s backstory. The movie places greater emphasis on her military experience, PTSD, and the trauma she carries from her service, while leaving out much of the difficult childhood and complicated relationship with her mother explored in the book.
Even smaller changes stood out to me, particularly the necklace and who gives it to Hannah. I personally would have preferred keeping that detail closer to the novel.
But I’ve always believed that if I finish a book and its adaptation with the same emotional response, I don’t necessarily mind changes to the story.
That’s how I felt about Guarding Stars. I can recognize that readers who loved certain elements of Center’s novel may feel differently, but the changes didn’t prevent me from enjoying the film.
I also had the opportunity to discuss these decisions, including some of the smaller differences, with the screenwriters in an interview for What’s on Netflix. Hearing the reasoning behind those choices helped me understand and appreciate them, even when I might have preferred the original version.

A Christmas romance with plenty of heart
What I particularly enjoyed about Guarding Stars is how much emotion it brings to the Christmas setting.
The romance between Hannah and Jack is central, but the family relationships give the movie much of its heart. Jack is dealing with the loss of his brother and years of distance from his family, while Hannah is experiencing Christmas traditions and a sense of belonging largely absent from her life.
It’s a lovely combination, and the cast makes it easy to care about these characters.
The final take: Guarding Stars is a good Christmas romance with wonderful leads, a warm supporting cast, and enough emotion to make the holiday setting feel meaningful. It isn’t a completely faithful adaptation of The Bodyguard, and I understand why some readers may miss parts of the novel. For me, though, it captures the feelings that made the book enjoyable in the first place.
And if you’re tired of rewatching Gilmore Girls or Gossip Girl but still want to spend some time with familiar television favorites, Netflix has you covered.
