Is It Cake? Halloween season 2 is coming to Netflix on October 9, 2026. Mikey Day returns as host for another three-episode Halloween competition, with six cake artists trying to fool a new group of celebrity judges.
Netflix announced the date alongside an official sneak peek and key art for the new season.
Is It Cake? Halloween season 2 brings in six new bakers
The new season features Bonne Bedingfield, Corinna Maguire, Frankie Velez, Mike Elder, Rodolfo Goncalves and Tiphani Anderson.
They’ll create Halloween-themed hyper-realistic cakes designed to fool the judges, with a cash prize and the title of Is It Cake? Halloween Champion going to the winner.
Season 2 will once again be a short run, consisting of three 40-minute episodes.
Wednesday stars are among this season’s guest judges
Each episode will bring in a different group of three celebrity judges.
Episode 1 features Bianca Belair, Blippi and Lil Rel Howery.
The second episode has a particularly Netflix-friendly lineup, with Wednesday stars Hunter Doohan, Isaac Ordonez and Joy Sunday serving as judges.
Cedric Yarbrough, Kristen Schaal and Paul Scheer will judge the third and final episode.
Is It Cake? Halloween season 2 is produced by Alfred Street Industries, with Dan Cutforth, Jane Lipsitz, Nan Strait, Dan Volpe and Andrew Wallace serving as executive producers.
All three episodes premiere October 9 on Netflix.
